Article title: High-Order Description of the Dynamics in FFAGs ... Field Reconstruction in Large Quadrupole Magnets Conceptual design of a superconducting quadrupole with elliptical ... Computation of High-order Maps to Multiple Machine Precision On Beam Dynamics Optimization Problems High-Order Maps for General Particle Optical Systems On Self-Consistent 4D Distributions ... Investigation and Optimization of Low-Energy Heavy-Ion ... Beam Based Feedback System for ILC Green's Function Technique in Forming of Intensive Beams Beam Dynamics Optimization in APF Accelerator Beam Dynamics Optimization for the XFEL Photo Injector Rigorous Global Optimization for Beam Physics Optimization of Radial Matching Section New Approach to RMS Emittance Optimization in RFQ Accelerator Optimization of Discharge Initiation Conditions in Tokamak ITER Evolutionary Algorithm for the Neutrino Factory Front End Design 6D Simulations of the Guggenheim Cooling Channel ... Nonlinear Tune Shift Calculation for the Tevatron Accelerator Estimation of the Region of Asymptotic Stability ... Plasma Stabilization on the Base of Model Predictive Control Optimization of the Discharge Initiation Program Control in Tokamak Some Problems of Nanoprobe Modeling Specrtal Approach to H-Optimization of Plasma Control Computer Assisted Proof of the Existence of High Period Fixed Points ... Parametric Optimization Methods for Tokamak Plasma Control Problem Robust Stability Analysis of Linear Periodic Systems with Time Delay Some H-optimization problems for ITER plasma control system Effects of the wiggler on the HLS storage ring
Please pick the article you are reviewing from the drop-down list.
Reviewer's name:
The reviewer's name will not be revealed to the author(s) of the article, please do not leave this field blank.
Summary: Please enter a brief summary of the article as you saw it.
Originality:
Originality or novelty describes the innovation factor of an article. An article that covers aspects of a topic that are rarely discussed or very new has a high originality rating. The originality influenced by the fact wether an article was previously published. An article that consists mainly of old and well known material can not be considered as "original".
Significance:
A high significance rating expresses a great impact of the article on a research topic. An article that presents important research results in a scientifically accurate way will achieve a high rating.
Presentation:
The presentation of the article includes its readability, the use of graphical material, the language, formal aspects, and the use of technical terms. A properly structured article is easy to read and that improves the understanding of the content.
Adequacy of citations:
The adequacy of citations ratings provides information about the accuracy of references and the appropriateness of citations of an article. The references serve to support the research results but they are also helpful for the interested reader to receive deeper insight into the topic. If the references are very specialized, hard to find or on the other hand too general, the adequacy of citations rating might be quite low.
Amount of rewriting:
The amount of rewriting provides an overview about the number of corrections and the amount of time that is neccessary to put the article into an acceptable form. If the article is acceptable with minor corrections, the amount of rewriting is "little" (which is, in this case, a positive rating). Article that is not usable and needs high effort to become publishable, will describe the amount of rewriting as "much".
Review: Main contributions, positive aspects, negative aspects, further comments, final recommendation: publish with no change, publish with minor corrections, major reworking required.
Specific comments: Particular comments and suggestions: page, line, comment.
Comments to the editors: Comments to the editors, will not be revealed to the author.
After pressing the "Submit" button your information will be transferred to the BDO server. Also, the PDF report will be generated based on the information you provided. You can save this report for your reference.